Hide menu

Results

It is no clear correlation between the studied explanatory variables and their impacts on the studied response variables.

One of the six investigated response variables were significant affected by the explanatory variables. Leaf thickness was significant affected but only if treatment and Tree density or Canopy cover were combined. For the other response variables, no significant effects were found between different response and explanatory variables (Table 2). Based on P-values from table 1 and means from table 2 (table 2). It is non-significant trends that leaf weight/cm2 are close to be significant when it is combined with canopy cover. Four of eight means were lowest in the recently thinned areas (stomatas, leaf size, leaf weight and tree density). Two means were lowest both in the unmanaged (leaf thickness and canopy cover) and formerly thinned areas (leaf weight/cm2 and tree vitality). When all explanatory and response variables were merged together, the R2value for the hole model are 8% and that is no significant p-value.

Table 1. Linear model of six response variables with interaction between time since conservation thinning and canopy cover or tree density. The p-value tests the hypothesis of no effect of the explanatory variable on the response variable. The test analyses if the explanatory variables are positively or negatively related to the measured response variables. P>0,05.

 

Response variables

Explanatory variables

P-value

Leaf thickness

Canopy cover

0.001*

Leaf thickness

Tree density

0.005*

Leaf Weight

Canopy cover

0.906

Leaf Weight

Tree density

0.974

Leaf weight cm2

Canopy cover

0.157

Leaf weight cm2

Tree density

0.459

Leaf size

Canopy cover

0.602

Leaf size

Tree density

0.504

Number of stomatas

Canopy cover

0.794

Number of stomatas

Tree density

0.454

Vitality

Canopy cover

0.286

Vitality

Tree density

0.401

All combined

All combined

0.590

   
   
   

 

 
 

 Table 2. Leaf anatomy variables representing the three treatments studied: stomatal density (numbers/mm2), leaf blade thickness (µm), leaf size (cm2), leaf weight (g), vitality (%), Canopy cover (%) and weight/cm2 (g/cm2). Data are the means and SD from the 72 oaks visited oaks. DF=2

 

  

 

Stomatas

Thickness

Size

Weight

Weight

/Cm2

Vitality

Tree

density

Canopy

cover

Formerly thinned areas (mean)

398

150,944

41,880

0,490

0,012

79,958

125,708

69,708

Recently thinned areas (mean)

375

127,486

37,229

0,471

0,013

84,583

83,667

65,958

Unmanaged areas (mean)

393

126,653

40,617

0,478

0,012

85,875

90,625

61,542

Formerly thinned areas (SD)

43,655

13,329

5,775

0,088

0,001

6,383

30,915

10,672

Recently thinned areas (SD)

32,801

10,086

2,363

0,041

0,013

4,283

51,156

16,424

Unmanaged areas (SD)

29,827

7,376

5,237

0,038

0,012

3,862

83,481

15,029

             

 

               
 
 
   
Fig 1. RDA plot that shows how the different groups of oaks are correlated to each other and how the different parameters (both explanatory and response variables are affecting each other). The red symbols are representing each of the 24 visited sites. Every group and their associated sites are circled by an eclipse.

The RDA plot (fig 1) are showing that two groups (Recently thinned areas and unmanaged area) are close related to each other. It also showing that the formerly thinned areas are separated from the others. Two different analysis were preformed to investigate if the three groups are statistically separeted from each other. Both show non-significant differences (table 3).

 

 

 

Table 3. One-way ANOVA studying if the different axis is separated from each other and if the different parameters are separated from each other. Data is the P and F-values and the DF for every test.

 

 

p-value

F-value

DF

Axis RDA1

0,498

3,043

1

Axis RDA 2

0,856

0,842

1

Parameters (treatment)

0,191

1,765

2

Parameter (Tree density)

0,726

0,282

1

Parameter (Canopy Cover)

0,881

0,122

1

 


Responsible for this page: Director of undergraduate studies Biology
Last updated: 05/22/19